Transforming Musicians into Songwriters

Deliberate Songwriting

Writing from the heart is fun, but if you aren't finishing your songs there is another step to take... deliberate songwriting takes your songwriting to the next level and saves both your time and your songs!
Deliberate Songwriting - taking the guesswork out of songwriting

Table of Contents

Use Deliberate Songwriting techniques to take the guesswork out of songwriting!

Intuitive songwriting is fun!

It’s the best way to write songs … you find the flow and write from the heart. But…

What do you do if your intuition slows down and you get stuck?

What if your song is 90% done… and you realize it’s not working and you can’t figure out why?

Is it time to trash this song too? 

Would you rather know what you are doing and decide what you want to accomplish before you invest time and effort in a song?

Intuitive Songwriting

Writing with only your intuition, can work to a point… but if it’s your only way, you are writing without planning or thinking it through.

Don’t believe anyone who tells you that:

  • Planning is boring, 
  • Stifles your creativity, or 
  • Spoils the joy in songwriting. 

Deciding on some of the details in advance forces you to be more creative because you focus your efforts and:

  • Save time by avoiding frustrations, instead of trying to solve them
  • Focusing your ideas to get the most out of your songs, and
  • Finishing more songs because you aren’t tossing them away half way through

Once your song is finished, you can explain your song and effectively publicize your music. You will also have a plan to share it… so people will actually listen to your song! And if you want to pitch it to an artist, you will have a better idea how to get them to listen to your song.

we got this face who needs a plan?, two border collies sitting in the front seats of a car, songwriting meme

Deliberate Songwriting

Instead of relying entirely on your intuition, you can start thinking ahead… who is your audience and what story do you want to tell them?

These questions will focus your writing and help you become deliberate with your songwriting. 

Actively answer them, that means write down your responses, don’t just think about them (that’s the deliberate part… you are already considering many of these things even if you aren’t conscious of it. 

You get clarity when you consciously work out the details by writing them down. Obviously you want to stop faking your songwriting or you wouldn’t still be reading….) 

Answer in any order that works for you, skip a few if they slow you down. Once you’ve done it a few times this only takes a few minutes.

The Fundamental Question is WIIFM? 

“What’s In It For Me?” .. why should anyone listen to your song… 

What will I get out of the song… a thrill, a cool beat, an emotional journey, a story, a new spin on a classic theme?

Communicate that and people will want to know more and listen to you. Let’s go through some smaller questions so you can it more effectively….

Who is Your Song For? 

Know your audience, write a song that they relate to, about things they are interested in, using words and lyrics that make sense to them!

  • Is this your usual audience, or a different demographic?
  • Who are your audience? 
  • What are their likes & dislikes? 
  • How do they talk?
  • What words and phrases do they use?
  • What about their… age (range), gender, social status, type of career, stage of life? 

Describe your audience in a few sentences.

Your dog song does not impress

What is Your Song About? 

  • What is the big idea?
  • What are the themes? 
  • What emotions are you writing about?
  • What happens in the song, what is the plot?

Describe the song in 1-2 sentences.

What Does Your Song Mean?

  • Is there a deeper meaning?
  • What figurative language (metaphors, similes, analogies, etc.) do you use in the song?

Describe what the song means to you in 1-2 sentences

Why is Your Song Cool?

  • What makes this song interesting?
  • What emotions are you writing about? 
  • What do you want people to feel?

Explain what makes this song interesting, exciting or worth listening to.

Why is Your Song Unique? 

  • What makes this song different from other songs about similar topics or themes?
  • What is your perspective on the theme? 
  • How is this different from other songs?

Explain the unique perspective of your song.

Don't Twist Yourself Up, guitar tuning peg

What Does Your Song Sound Like? 

As much as every songwriter strives to be a unique individual, you are a product of all the music you have ever listened to… your music reflects this.

Reference tracks: a traditional mixing hack, choose some songs with a similar sound to compare your song to as you mix it. Having a sonic model to compare a work in progress to, helps you create the sound you want. It might be the sound of the drum kit, or the tone of a guitar, the quality of the lead vocals or the vibe that you are trying to create. 

I choose reference tracks for writing models while I am writing a song. The connection could be the theme or subject, the sound of a song section that I want to emulate or a chord progression that I want to adapt for my own song.

Choosing reference tracks before you finish the song (whether for writing, or mixing) gives you a start to describing the song when you post it later.

Give your audience an idea of what your song sounds like before hearing it…

Explain what the song sounds like (include specific songs &/or artists/bands).

Learn how to verbally describe your music and your sound in Create Your Musical Elevator Pitch!

What is the Style or Genre of Your Song?

Many songs can fit more than one musical style or genre… so list the possible styles and genres (include specific artists or bands).

Now We Can Deliberately Answer… What’s In It For Me?

The key question to address to get anyone interested in your music (or anything else!)

In most situations, you need to capture someone’s attention before they even get to hear your music… without being able to answer “what’s in it for me” you’ve already lost your audience.

Review your previous answers and summarize the best ones and create a written reason for your audience to listen to your song.

You can get people interested in your music before they hear it by writing better descriptions: Get More Social Love for Your Songs.

Grey cat lying on his back "Your new song is awesome... but rub my belly"

What Type of Song Are Your Deliberately Writing?

Bands, Artists, and Singer-Songwriters write and perform different types of songs. They have different goals and have different assumptions about their songs. (These three categories are one way I analyze songs, there are always exceptions!)

Band Songs

In a band, typically all musicians are partners, everyone has a voice in creating the music and needs to be interested in what they are performing. It can be tough to write for an established band that plays originals because they usually write their own. If you know some members you might have a way in, but it is probably better to try co-writing with the main songwriter.

Band: Musical Considerations

Band songs are often music focused (the lyrics can be secondary), insert a solo, provide riffs, and more arrangement ideas. The musicians want to know what and how to play the song… an acoustic guitar / vocal demo won’t cut it.

Artist Songs

An artist is the leader, musicians are hired and need to be paid for what they perform. So the artist (with their manager, producer, even their entourage) has to love a song.

Artist: Musical Considerations

Make the artist sound and look good. Write to their singing strengths, songs are usually focused on the vocals. If there is an instrumental solo, keep it short. An artist who plays an instrument will showcase it in the arrangement.

Singer-Songwriter Songs

A singer-songwriter is an artist that writes the majority of their songs. Some perform alone, others hire a band. A singer/songwriter is unlikely to record your song, they prefer to record their own songs. You can co-write with some singer-songwriters… present them with an interesting idea, not a completed song, so they can contribute to the creation of the song.

Singer-Songwriter: Musical Considerations

Songs are more personal, and usually focus more on lyrics than the music. Often there are more words in the song that in other types of songs. Expect the songwriting to be more sophisticated. The lyrics might be more complicated, poetic or obscure. 

Choose the type of song: band, artist or singer-songwriter.

Love your song, let me turn it up, grey cat sleeping with face on a remote control

What is Your Target Performer?

Are you the best person to record this song or do you have another artist in mind?

If you are writing a song for another artist to cover, consider:

  • If they write songs, your best chance for a cut is to co-write with them. 
  • Do they record/perform covers?
  • Do they co-write with others?
  • Do they know me, know who I am?
  • Who do I know that knows them?

Who are:

  • A-level artists that could cut your song?
  • Local artists that could cut your song?
  • List contact information or ways to contact these local artists.

WIIFT? (What’s In It For Them?)

  • Does the song make the artist look/feel good?
  • Would the artist want to perform your song?
  • If your song became a hit, would they want to perform it every night for the rest of their career?
  • Is it consistent with their brand?
  • What similar songs have they recorded/performed? How is your song different?
  • Could this song be a different song to add to their repertoire?

How would cutting your song would benefit the artist?

How will they hear the song?

Whether you are planning to record yourself or pitch to another artist, your audience needs to hear your song to make it complete….

Outline your demo plan (including professional studio or home studio, musicians / vocalists, mixer, mastering).

For profession recording tips: How to Professionally Record Your Songs. If you’re recording in your home studio, mixing or mastering your own songs be sure it’s the highest quality you can make.

Deliberate Songwriting: Summary

Preparation and planning saves me time and helps me write better, more focused songs. Knowing my goals and having a clear idea of where I want to take a song helps me get there!

I use deliberate songwriting through the entire songwriting process. I still love intuitive songwriting, but it’s so much faster for me when I know where I want to take a song as I’m writing it!

Leave a comment to help other songwriters:

What deliberate steps and planning do you use in your songwriting process?

More Deliberate Songwriting Articles 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Picture of Trevor Dimoff

Trevor Dimoff

Trevor Dimoff has taught, played and written music professionally for the last 25+ years.

If you can play songs,
you can learn to write songs…

How to Write a Song Chorus:
Lyrics, Melody & Chords...

Learn a deliberate songwriting process for free...

How to Write a Song Chorus,
the lyrics, melody & chords